Step Three: Evaluate Between-Cluster Differences
- Identify any significant differences between DAS clusters
If there are significant and unusual differences between any pair of cluster
scores , the GCA must be interpreted with caution. As with almost any cognitive
test that assesses multiple cognitive abilities, differences among the abilities
can often lead to important interpretive hypotheses. Between-Cluster differences
can occur for a number of different reasons, including learning disabilities,
different interests, strengths/difficulties working under time pressures,
strengths/deficits in information processing, sensory impairments, cognitive
styles, or brain injury. Neither the presence nor absence of Between-Cluster
differences is by itself sufficient to diagnose or rule out any disability.
The DAS Introductory and Technical Handbook Table B.1. and Table B.4.
(pp. 290-292) provides the examiner with information about the difference
required for statistical significance for these Between-Cluster comparisons.
Rounded mean values at the .05 significance level are also found on the protocol
Summary Page. For School-Age children, the mean values for each of the three
comparisons is approximately 16 points, while for Preschool children the
Verbal/Nonverbal mean value is 14 points.
When each of the V/NVR/Sp comparison differences is less than the critical
values for significance, the GCA is most likely a reliable total. If there is no
compelling reason to bypass the statistical approach to interpretation (e.g.,
significant scatter between the scores that make up the clusters; the effects of
retesting), one may infer that the person displays fairly equal abilities
whether through verbal expression of concepts, knowledge, and reasoning; through
complex nonverbal inductive reasoning; or through complex visual-spatial
processing.
- Identify the frequency of any observed significant differences
As noted above, a statistically significant difference between certain
cognitive abilities is often found frequently in the general population of
children. If a DAS Cluster differs significantly from any other Cluster on the
test, examiners must determine the base-rate frequency of the observed
difference. The Between-Cluster differences shown by various percentages of the
standardization sample are found in Tables B.4. and B.5. in the DAS Introductory
and Technical Handbook. In general, Preschool Verbal and Nonverbal Clusters
would need to differ by approximately 25 points in order to approach a level
seen in only 10% of the population. For the School-Age clusters, a difference
between clusters must be between 21 and 24 points to be considered unusual. It
must again be noted that these tables, in the DAS Introductory and Technical
Handbook, are derived from the absolute value of the difference and
disregard the nature of the discrepancy (e.g., V > NVR, NVR > V). As
before, to estimate the frequency of a particular specific cluster comparison in
one direction, halve the size of the percentage shown in these tables.
If there are differences that are significant and unusual, interpret subtests
rather than their cluster